The Best Fried Chicken Sandwich in Town

A person holding a dog

The past few years, Popeye sesame Chicken sandwiches have been all the rave, but how about this fresh homemade version, and are they even better? Can you really top a traditional fried chicken sandwich? Is it more delicious than those from your local diner? While delicious, it would definitely need an upgrade.

It’s difficult to think there is a traditional southern fried chicken sandwich that can top Popeye’s. Theirs is baked with fresh veggies on a golden brown bun, and while delicious, sometimes the sandwich could use a little something extra. I went through a phase where I wasn’t even going to eat it because I thought there was nothing more that could top it.

Best Fried Chicken Sandwich

A sandwich sitting on top of a wooden cutting board

So how did I get over that? It took some trial and error, but I finally found what I needed to make my favorite south Florida favorite the best-fried chicken sandwich in town. The secret to their success is their crunchy, flavorful biscuit batter. You just can’t beat the taste of well-prepared biscuit batter.

The best-fried chicken sandwich in NYC is juicy, spicy, fresh, and dumplings-like. It must be said, however, that the chef makes sure to keep the veggies in. Otherwise, this sandwich is just a bland, standard chicken bread. Traditionally, the Gothamist biscuit has been seasoned with garlic powder, black pepper, and chili powder. They are not raw; they are lightly battered with breadcrumbs, which makes them gooey and rich.

Things To Know

A close up of a hand holding a sandwich

This Gothamist may not offer many pickles, but they are definitely a welcome sight and delicious. The classic sandwich base is made of crisp white bread with a light tomato or marinara sauce on the side. On the side, you can choose from American, New York Style, Hamburgers, Cheddar, Swiss, or Cheese on a split cracker. If you are really adventurous and love to experiment, you might like to try their Asian version called the Bamboo Buns. Instead of the traditional white bun base, they have a red or blue bun with your choice of vegetables as the toppings.

Although you are not going to find the traditional chicken-lunch sandwich here, there are a few places in NYC that do serve this delectable fare. The Cheesecake Shop has an absolutely delicious chicken sandwich made with a spicy tuna salad as the base. Then, for lunch or dinner, you can satisfy your sweet tooth at the nearby Panini Bar. With its simple sandwich format, you can choose from ham, Swiss, or Colby-jack cheese.

For something a little more upscale, head to Cake Shop, which serves up a savory-sweet-and-salty grilled sandwich that is sure to satisfy. Their baked potato and coleslaw sandwiches are filled with your favorite barbecue flavors and served on a wood plank with a tasty accompaniment of fresh grilled vegetables. If you want to go more casual, head over to Totonno’s BBQ Sauce and Shrimp Truck, which offers a juicy, tangy, and tasty option for your sandwiches. The restaurant’s popular baked potato and coleslaw sandwiches are also available on weekdays, as well as for lunch and dinner. Although it does not use mayonnaise, their creamy potato dip is a tasty way to end your meal.

Bottom Line

For chicken lovers, there are several places that serve a chicken slaw that is sure to please. Head to Lumberyard Slaw House for their amazing spicy and tangy slaw that is sure to heat up your taste buds. If you are looking for something with a little more kick, head to Tommy’s Toss Back Slaw, which serves up a tangy cornmeal slaw with Pickles, garlic, and lemon. For chicken lovers who enjoy a sweeter selection, head to Sweet Tomatoes, which serves up traditional Italian chicken salad topped with Pecans and shaved parmesan.

Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter